Greenwash – Part 3

I neglected yesterday to address Day 340 of the “Our Green Year” blog. This entry needs to singled out as a clusterfuck of all that is wrong with this blog. This blog post focuses on using natural remedies for some very serious medical conditions and problems. Even though Craig assures us that he and Layla are not doctors they feel no hesitation in recommending ‘natural’ cures to their readers.

So, let’s begin with the advice dispensing:

If you are feeling down, instead of taking anti-depressants, you can put a couple of drops of lavender oil on your temples. This can temporarily relieve anxieties and help calm you. Having lavender smells in your home or office will also help.

First of all, doctors do not prescribe anti-depressants for those ‘feeling a little bit down.’ Instead they are far more likely to suggest counseling, self-care and making some changes in one’s life to improve mood.1 If someone has severe enough depression that it requires anti-depressants then a little lavender oil on the temples is not going to help. Clearly neither Craig nor Layla or anyone close to them has suffered from depression or they would not write such drivel. As someone who has recently joined the ‘anti-depressant’ club as a result of chronic illness and anxiety I have to say that a little lavender oil would not have done anything for me. I only went on the anti-depressants when my anxiety and depression were almost debilitating. If counseling, self-care and making changes in my life didn’t work why would lavender oil? Moreover, the insinuation that people who are ‘a little bit down’ would take antidepressants is insulting. Mental health is a very complex and serious issue and not one to be taken lightly. Quite frankly, I was insulted by this post and I am sure many others were as well.

Continuing with the ‘mood’ theme:

Another tip for your mood is to buy 100 percent natural flower essences. What are those? Well they are flowers you grow outside with nothing but water and the sun. Flowers are a great way to add nice aromas and balance your mood.

Now everyone likes to get flowers. They smell nice and looking at them may make you feel a little happier especially if they come from someone special. I am at a loss as to what they could do for one’s mood pharmacologically speaking.

This one is great:

If you are having troubles with high blood pressure, try some nice herbal teas or use some dandelion tea.

I think if you have high blood pressure you need to be making dietary and exercise changes and taking medication if it is recommended by your doctor. I am not sure which herbal teas he would be referring to but I think if you drank any tea that had any affect on your blood pressure and you were taking medication, you may lower it to dangerous levels. This piece of advise is dangerous. Please, consult your doctor before you take any herbal remedies to deal with high blood pressure.

More condescension in this little exercept:

If you have trouble with diabetes, asthma or any number of conditions, you can contact a herbalist and see what options are available to you. Make sure you choose someone who has credentials and training with herbs and you should be able to get some very beneficial herbs.

I am sorry but people don’t ‘have trouble with asthma or diabetes’ they have them. End of conversation. Quite frankly as one who has asthma I would not give up my inhalers for any herbal remedy. If I am having an asthma attack I need to fix it, now! People with diabetes risk losing limbs, their sight and kidney function if their disease is not managed. I am not sure what a ‘herbalist’ can do for these conditions but I would bet they are far better treated by a medical doctor.

Craig ends this post stating:

So, unless it is a severe medical issue that only a doctor can help with, we will be using natural remedies for minor things like colds, flus, aches, pains, headaches and more.

Given that he has addressed severe medical issues like depression, diabetes and high blood pressure as diseases that can be treated with natural remedies I wonder what he would consider a serious disease?

1 I am also pretty sure they are not going to recommend lavender oil. Just my thoughts but hey, I am not a doctor.

Advertisements
Published in: on April 8, 2009 at 10:46 am  Comments (9)  
Tags:

The URI to TrackBack this entry is: https://shihtzustaff.wordpress.com/2009/04/08/greenwash-part-3/trackback/

RSS feed for comments on this post.

9 CommentsLeave a comment

  1. The incredible, self-righteous condescension–not to mention self-delusion–of these schmucks floors me.
    But it doesn’t really surprise me, either, if you see what I mean…

  2. Oh my freaking God. I was so angry when I read this post that I just didn’t know what to say about it. Luckily, and as usual, you have been very articulate and have basically stated in a rational way exactly what I was thinking, too.

    Taking a tea or a supplement to deal with colds, headaches, or other “minor” issues is one thing, but tackling the serious issues he did in this post, like diabetes and depression, was just too much for me.

    • I think he was incredibly callous and showed huge disregard for the safety of his readers. He also insulted many of us with mental health issues by telling us that a little lavender oil on the temples will treat our medical conditions. By suggesting such trite treatments for serious medical conditions he is contributing to the stigma attached to mental health issues. I can’t wait for day 365 – hopefully then this will be over.

  3. Great post. You are so right. This whole “lavender oil” thing only perpetuates the stigma of mental illness… and implies high blood pressure is not such a big deal. BTW I love the word “clusterfuck”. I almost had one of those once, but it never came to fruition. LOL

    • Which post did you leave it on?

  4. I left a comment on their site about this. We’ll see if it makes it past moderation.

    ūüėČ

    • As a person living with many of the conditions Craig the Kook mentioned, I truly think I would be dead due to natural (or unnatural) causes within months if I took his “non-medical” advice. There are no oils, plants or bouquets of daisies that are going to cure my depression, migraines, or high blood pressure, although maybe Craig can come up with some tree bark or wild mushroom cure for MS. Who needs 1250 mg of prednisone a day for three days when birch bark soup or pine cone stew can stop relapses from happening?
      Fortunately I doubt that any rational, educated, sane person would give Craig’s “insights” any credence. The man uses coffee grounds as a body wash and pisses on his petunias. I think he lost all rational thought on day two or three of his green year.

  5. Ah, Deb, you totally crack me up.

    Incidentally: do you have an anniversary coming up? If so, give seeds and locally grown weeds!

  6. Dandelions and ragweed it is. Plus, Craig posted about making one’s own paper at some point last year….damn, I won’t even have to buy a card. With all the money I save, I’ll be able to buy a shitload of wooden buttons!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: